Medicare and IRMAA: How Your Income Decisions Affect Your Premiums
5 min read
If you're approaching Medicare or already enrolled here in Mentor, Ohio, you've probably heard the term IRMAA tossed around, usually followed by a confused look. IRMAA stands for Income-Related Monthly Adjustment Amount, and it's simply an extra premium surcharge added to Medicare Part B and Part D for people whose income falls above certain levels.
Here's the part that trips people up: IRMAA isn't based on your income this year. It's based on your income from two years ago. For example, your 2026 Medicare premiums are generally determined using your 2024 tax return. That lag matters a lot when you're making financial decisions, because a choice you make today might not show up as a higher premium until two years from now, long after the decision is behind you.
This is exactly why we think about IRMAA as part of the whole picture, not as an isolated Medicare issue.
Key takeaways
- IRMAA is a surcharge on Medicare Part B and Part D premiums for higher earners, not a tax or a penalty.
- Your premium in a given year is generally based on your modified adjusted gross income (MAGI) from two years prior.
- Roth conversions, RMDs, and Social Security claiming decisions can all raise MAGI in the year they happen.
- A single large income event, even a one-time one, can bump you into a higher IRMAA bracket.
- Planning income across years, not just within a single year, is often the key to managing IRMAA exposure.
What counts toward the IRMAA calculation
Medicare uses your modified adjusted gross income, which is generally your adjusted gross income plus any tax-exempt interest, to determine whether IRMAA applies and at what level. This can include:
- Wages and self-employment income
- Capital gains from selling investments or property
- IRA and retirement account withdrawals, including RMDs
- Roth conversion amounts
- Interest, dividends, and tax-exempt municipal bond interest
- Taxable pension and annuity distributions
Notice that tax-exempt interest is on that list. A lot of people assume municipal bond income is invisible to Medicare. It isn't exempt from the IRMAA calculation, even though it isn't taxed as ordinary income.
Three decisions that commonly affect IRMAA
Roth conversions
Converting pre-tax retirement dollars to a Roth IRA means recognizing that income in the year of the conversion. A large conversion can push your MAGI up enough in that one year to trigger IRMAA two years later. That doesn't mean conversions are a bad idea — it means the size and timing deserve real thought, not a single all-at-once move.
Required Minimum Distributions
Once RMDs begin, they add directly to your taxable income every year, whether you need the cash or not. Because RMDs tend to grow over time, some retirees find their income (and their IRMAA bracket) creeps upward well into retirement, even without any other changes to their finances.
Social Security claiming timing
When you choose to start Social Security affects your overall income picture in any given year, and combined with other income sources, it can shift your total MAGI. Claiming decisions are rarely just about the monthly benefit amount — they interact with everything else happening in your tax return that year.
Why this isn't a one-year decision
Because of the two-year lookback, a decision you make this year quietly shows up in your Medicare premium bill two years from now. By the time the higher premium notice arrives, it's too late to undo the original decision. That's the whole point of planning these moves together, rather than reacting to each one separately. A Roth conversion strategy that ignores IRMAA, or an RMD withdrawal plan that doesn't consider Social Security timing, misses pieces of the puzzle that are all connected.
Common mistakes to avoid
- Doing a large Roth conversion in a single year without modeling the IRMAA impact two years out.
- Assuming retirement automatically lowers your income enough to avoid IRMAA.
- Forgetting that both spouses on Medicare can each be assessed IRMAA individually.
- Ignoring tax-exempt interest when estimating MAGI.
- Not reviewing the Social Security notice carefully when it arrives, or missing the appeal window if a life-changing event reduced your income.
When to talk with us
IRMAA is one of those planning areas that rarely stands alone. It touches Roth conversion strategy, RMD timing, Social Security claiming, and overall tax planning, all at once. If you're weighing a conversion, approaching RMD age, or deciding when to claim Social Security, it's worth looking at the whole picture before making a move.
If you'd like a deeper look at how to think through conversions with IRMAA in mind, we put together a free guide, the Roth Conversions for Pre-Retirees Playbook, that walks through exactly this. Schedule a free retirement assessment with us if you'd like to talk through your own situation.
Frequently asked questions
Is IRMAA a tax? No. It's a premium surcharge added to Medicare Part B and Part D for people above certain income thresholds, not a separate tax.
What income year does Medicare use for my premium? Generally, Medicare uses income from the tax return filed two years earlier. For 2026 premiums, that typically means your 2024 return.
Does a Roth conversion get taxed twice because of IRMAA? No. IRMAA is a premium adjustment, not additional income tax. But the conversion amount does count toward MAGI, which can affect your premium two years later.
Can retiring lower my IRMAA? It might, but not immediately. Because of the two-year lookback, your premiums may still reflect a higher-income year even after you've retired.
Do both spouses pay IRMAA if we file jointly? If both spouses are on Medicare and the household's MAGI falls into an applicable tier, each spouse can be individually assessed an IRMAA amount.
What if my income dropped because of a life event, like retirement or losing a spouse? You may be able to request that Social Security use more recent income information. Review your notice and consider reaching out to Social Security directly to understand your options.
Sources
This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute personalized financial, tax, or legal advice. Benjamin A. Simerly, CFP®, founder of Lakehouse Family Wealth, offers advisory services through Cambridge Investment Research Advisors, Inc., a Registered Investment Adviser. Lakehouse Family Wealth is not affiliated with Cambridge.