Back to the blog
Tax Planning

Roth Conversion Mistakes Pre-Retirees Make (and How to Avoid Them)

4 min read

A Roth conversion can be one of the smartest moves in a retirement plan. It can also backfire if the timing, the amount, or the bigger picture gets overlooked. If you're weighing a conversion, here are the mistakes we see most often among pre-retirees here in Mentor, Ohio, and how to sidestep them.

Key takeaways

  • Converting a large balance in a single year can push you into a higher tax bracket and increase future Medicare premiums.
  • A conversion decision should be made alongside your full financial picture, not as a standalone tax move.
  • Converting only pays off if you have a plan for how and when you'll use the money in retirement.
  • Each conversion has its own five-year waiting period before earnings can be withdrawn tax and penalty free.
  • This is a decision with enough moving parts that it is worth working through with someone who can see the whole picture.

Converting too much in one year

The biggest misstep is treating a Roth conversion like an all-or-nothing decision. Converting a large balance in a single year can push you into a higher tax bracket, trigger higher Medicare premiums down the road, or create a tax bill that outweighs the long-term benefit. Most pre-retirees are better served by converting in smaller chunks over several years, filling up the lower tax brackets without spilling into the next one.

Ignoring the "whole picture"

A Roth conversion doesn't happen in isolation. It adds to your taxable income for the year, which can ripple into things like how much of your Social Security benefit is taxed, Medicare premium surcharges (IRMAA), and eligibility for certain credits. A conversion decision should always be made alongside a look at your full financial life, not as a standalone tax move.

Converting without a withdrawal strategy

Converting to a Roth only pays off if you have a plan for how and when you'll use those funds in retirement. Without that plan, it's easy to convert more than you'll actually benefit from, or to miss the chance to draw on Roth dollars strategically in years when it would help you the most.

Forgetting the five-year rule

Each Roth conversion has its own five-year waiting period before earnings can be withdrawn tax and penalty free. Convert in several different years, and you can end up tracking several different five-year clocks at once. Losing track of this detail is one of the more common surprises we see.

Going it alone on a complex decision

Tax brackets, Medicare premiums, Social Security timing, and your overall investment mix all interact with a conversion decision. Getting a second set of eyes on how these pieces fit together is often the difference between a conversion that helps and one that creates an unexpected tax bill.

When to talk with us

A Roth conversion isn't right or wrong in a vacuum — it's right or wrong for your specific situation and timeline. If you're considering a conversion, it's worth reviewing your numbers before you act rather than after. Schedule a free retirement assessment with us to talk through whether a conversion makes sense for you, or download our free guide below to learn more about how conversions work for pre-retirees. Curious what else we'd want you to ask before working with any advisor? See our answers to the CFP Board's 10 questions.

Sources

This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute personalized financial, tax, or legal advice. Benjamin A. Simerly, CFP®, founder of Lakehouse Family Wealth, offers advisory services through Cambridge Investment Research Advisors, Inc., a Registered Investment Adviser. Lakehouse Family Wealth is not affiliated with Cambridge.