Tax-Efficient Withdrawal Order: Which Accounts to Spend Down First in Retirement
5 min read
One of the most common questions we hear from people approaching retirement here in Mentor, Ohio is simple: once I stop working, which account do I pull money from first?
There is no IRS-mandated order for this. Instead, most financial planners use a conventional starting sequence: spend down taxable (brokerage) accounts first, then tax-deferred accounts like traditional IRAs and 401(k)s, and save Roth accounts for last. It is a sensible default. But it is only a default, not a rule that fits every household, and leaning on it too rigidly can leave money on the table.
Key takeaways
- The "taxable, then tax-deferred, then Roth" order is a reasonable starting point, not a one-size-fits-all rule.
- Required minimum distributions (RMDs) on most traditional accounts generally begin at age 73 and must be factored into any withdrawal plan.
- The right order depends on your tax brackets, Social Security timing, Medicare premiums, and how much is sitting in each type of account.
- Roth conversions done earlier in retirement can build a pool of tax-free money that gives you more flexibility later.
- A plan that blends withdrawals across all three account types, year by year, often works better than a strict sequence.
The conventional wisdom (and why it exists)
The logic behind the standard order is straightforward. Taxable accounts are spent first because gains there are often taxed at more favorable capital gains rates, and you are simply drawing down money that has already been taxed once. Tax-deferred accounts come next, since withdrawals are taxed as ordinary income and you generally want to let that money keep growing tax-deferred as long as possible. Roth accounts are saved for last because qualified withdrawals are generally tax-free, and Roth IRAs owned by the original owner are not currently subject to lifetime RMDs.
Followed strictly, though, this order has a quiet downside. If you spend only taxable money for years while your traditional IRA or 401(k) keeps growing untouched, you can end up with a very large tax-deferred balance by the time RMDs kick in. That can push you into a higher tax bracket than necessary, right at the point when you have the least flexibility to manage it.
Why the order isn't one-size-fits-all
Your actual withdrawal order should take your whole financial picture into account, not just account type. A few of the biggest factors:
Tax brackets, this year and in the future
If you find yourself in a lower tax bracket in the early retirement years, before Social Security and RMDs begin, that can be a window to take some income from tax-deferred accounts (or convert some to Roth) at a lower rate than you might face later.
Social Security timing
When you claim Social Security affects your taxable income in any given year, which in turn affects how much room you have to draw from tax-deferred accounts without jumping brackets. When to start Social Security is its own decision, but it is tightly connected to withdrawal sequencing.
Medicare IRMAA
Higher income in a given year, including large tax-deferred withdrawals or Roth conversions, can trigger higher Medicare Part B and Part D premiums through the income-related monthly adjustment amount (IRMAA). That is a real cost that is easy to overlook if you are only thinking about income tax.
Required minimum distributions
RMDs on traditional IRAs and most employer plans generally begin at age 73. Once they start, you are required to take them whether you need the cash or not, and failing to take the full amount by the deadline can trigger an excise tax. A withdrawal plan that ignores future RMDs can end up forcing larger-than-necessary taxable income later in retirement.
Where Roth conversions fit in
This is where the planning gets interesting. Doing partial Roth conversions during lower-income years — say, the gap years between retiring and when Social Security and RMDs begin — moves money from a tax-deferred account into a Roth account. You pay tax on the converted amount now, at what may be a lower rate than you would pay later.
The real payoff shows up down the road. Once that money is in a Roth, it can generally be withdrawn tax-free. That means in a future year when you need extra cash for something like a major expense, you have a choice: pull from the tax-deferred account and add to your ordinary income, or pull from the Roth and leave your taxable income (and your Medicare premiums) right where they are. That flexibility — having a lever you can pull without tax consequences — is often more valuable than people expect.
Common mistakes to avoid
- Following the default order mechanically, regardless of your bracket, RMDs, or Medicare situation.
- Letting a traditional IRA or 401(k) balance grow unchecked for years, only to face large RMDs and a higher bracket later.
- Assuming Roth withdrawals should never be touched. Used selectively, they can keep you out of a higher bracket or avoid an IRMAA surcharge.
- Treating a Roth conversion as automatically a good idea. Conversions create taxable income in the year you do them, so the math depends on your current versus expected future rates.
- Ignoring Social Security timing when deciding how much to withdraw or convert in a given year.
When to talk with us
Every family's situation is different. The accounts you hold, the income you expect from Social Security and pensions, your health care costs, and your goals for what you want to leave behind all factor into the right withdrawal order for you. If you would like help thinking through how to sequence withdrawals across your accounts, or whether Roth conversions make sense in your situation, schedule a free retirement assessment with us.
We put together a free guide, the Roth Conversions for Pre-Retirees Playbook, that walks through how conversions can be used to build tax-free flexibility heading into retirement.
Sources
This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute personalized financial, tax, or legal advice. Benjamin A. Simerly, CFP®, founder of Lakehouse Family Wealth, offers advisory services through Cambridge Investment Research Advisors, Inc., a Registered Investment Adviser. Lakehouse Family Wealth is not affiliated with Cambridge.